Purebred German Shepherd vs Mix (which do you prefer?)

If you’ve ever thought about getting a new German shepherd dog, you surely will wonder: which is the better breed, between the purebred German Shepherd vs mix breed?

That’s exactly what we’re going to write about today.

German Shepherds were created in 1899. They were initially developed as working dogs to herd and protect sheep under Captain Max von Stephanitz’s direction. He was a former captain in the cavalry and a student at the Berlin Veterinary College who firmly believed that working dogs should be produced.

In Western Australia, the first German Shepherds came to the continent in 1904. They had the moniker “German Sheep Dogs.” Around 1925, they traveled to Melbourne before eventually crossing Australia.

Recommended articles:

They have been a favorite dog to many across the world, but there have been a few mix-breeds of the German shepherd dog. This kept many owners wondering which could be better after all.

You can be convinced that a purebred dog is better because you know its parents, how big they’ll be, and other details.

On the other hand, you may think mixed-breed dogs are better because you’ve heard that they’re often healthier due to hybridization or heterosis. This means that a cross-bred offspring will often show qualities that are superior to those of purebred GS dogs.

We can generalize all day long, but the best way to know which is better for your dog’s long-term health and well-being is to look at their DNA.

This is one of the miracles of living in the modern world. I know that when many of us think of DNA tests, we think of finding out what breed a dog is, but there is much more. There are many important things that you could learn by testing your dog’s DNA.

Forty percent of dogs will suffer from a disease they inherited; that’s why it’s so important to know as much as you can about your dog’s genetics.

If you know what conditions your individual dog is predisposed to, you and your vet can begin taking preventative action as early as possible, which might help them live longer and save you money.

For example, your dog could have genes associated with bladder stones, but some bladder stones can actually be prevented with an appropriate diet.

Purebred German Shepherds Vs Mix: Factors to Consider When Adopting One

Response to training

It’s hard to tell the difference when you train a mixed breed dog versus a purebred dog, and that’s because every single dog is an individual, and their personalities are shaped by so much more than arbitrary breed labels.

Sometimes stereotypes are true for some individuals, but anecdotal data about a breed’s behavior in general is far from reliable when you’re focusing on an individual dog. The variations in their personalities from dog to dog are what should govern how you raise and care for them, not what they’re supposed to be, if you’re to choose between a mixed-breed dog and a purebred German shepherd dog.

Read also>> Red and Black German Shepherds: 7 Interesting Facts and Pictures

Cost of adoption

Experience often comes from animal shelters, and it’s more affordable with a low adoption fee when you get a mixed breed. This, however, depends on the breed with which it’s mixed. This can make the adoption of a mixed breed less affordable or costlier.

It also depends on the value placed on both breeds, which is determined by the location from which you are adopting.


Sometimes, when you get a mixed-breed puppy, you have no idea how big they’re going to be or how much they’re going to shed. However, you might find that if you adopt a purebred German shepherd, you might just have the best dog ever because you crave it so much.

On the other hand, maybe you prefer a purebred dog for some reason. Such reasons may include the dogs’ size, general appearance, and physical abilities.

Health condition

Which is healthier, purebred German Shepherd dogs or mixed-breed dogs? Well, most genetic conditions are recessive, which means that purebreds are more likely to get them because they’re more likely to inherit two copies of the same gene—one from each parent.

Now, generally, when you have a smaller gene pool, the odds of your offspring inheriting a genetic disease are higher. However, this also means that purebred German Shepherd dogs are more likely to have predictable genetic conditions, which in the past may have been preferable to not having any idea what you’re going to get.

Of course, a DNA test makes this point virtually irrelevant because you can find out your individual dog’s genetic risk regardless of their breed or breed mixed with, and that is a game-changer.

I can’t stress enough how easy it is to get a wealth of vital information with a basic salivary set. You just take this cotton swab right here and wipe the inside of their mouth.

All being well, you can get the DNA test, seal it up, and send it in, and you’ll get this detailed, easy-to-understand, and fun report that explains your dog’s genetic conditions and what they need.

Another great advantage for those of you with mutts is that you’ll get a really accurate breakdown of your dog’s breed mix, which is so cool. They’ll even be able to tell you your dog’s ideal weight and their approximate age, based on their individual genetics.

I can’t tell you how much fun it is to look at your dog’s family tree all the way back to their grandparents. Regardless of whether or not you choose a purebred German Shepherd dog or a mixed-breed dog, they are both fantastic choices.


To conclude which is better between a purebred German shepherd and a mixed is very relative here, as it cannot be discussed in isolation.Those willing to adopt a German shepherd dog have to take into consideration the various issues as analyzed here.

You can navigate other posts to read more about German shepherds and know how to train your dog properly to protect your family, right from puppyhood to adulthood. Thanks for reading, and I hope to have you back. If you want to support our work, a tip from you will go a long way, no matter how small.